Labate Sues Trice For $21.2 Million

Submitted by RookHouse on Thu, 10/30/2008 at 5:24pm.

The Edward Labate vs Ed Trice saga has come to a climactic end.  Mr. Labate won his court battle over Trice and was awarded 21.2 million dollars in a civil action suit on October 16th.

To view an actual copy of the court order, click here: http://www.rookhouse.com/blog/?p=314

Some of you will recall that Trice was attempting to collect money from unsuspecting chess fans for a bogus edition of a famous Bobby Fischer publication, calling it “My 61 Memorable Games”.  After approaching Labate with this proposition and promptly being turned down, an angry Trice attempted to lay blame on Labate as being the party behind this disrespectful and unlawful hoax.

Many accusations and battles ensued between these two on several chess sites all over the internet, with Trice constantly being proven wrong and continuing to spin an elaborate web of lies and false statements. 

It got to the point where legal action was the final recourse to prove once and for all who was telling the truth in this very public war of words.  The court system awarded a lawsuit in favor of Labate and ordered Trice to cease his libelous and slanderous attacks in all forms of media.

It is good to see this all come to an end and even better to see that the court system works.  Trice thought that he was above the law and completely untouchable.  He believed that his lies and unlawful actions would never come back on him …… but he was definitely wrong.

» posted in Other
 

Comments:

by staggerlee - 2 months ago
Kansas United States
Member Since: Mar 2008
Member Points: 514

Word dis be Trice da rappa

by IPA-Ray - 2 months ago
South Park, PA United States
Member Since: May 2008
Member Points: 207

The amount awarded is the amount sued for. When Trice failed to defend, the judge amount just awarded the amount requested. Labate should not expect a check in the mail.

by gabrielconroy - 2 months ago
London United Kingdom
Member Since: May 2008
Member Points: 391

Cockatrice?

by playu2 - 2 months ago
United States
Member Since: Aug 2008
Member Points: 11

I don't know a thing about this dispute but I thought a couple of things might be worth mentioning. First the judgment appears to be based on a default; it may later be set aside, challenged on jurisdictional grounds, or appealed. The award was relatively large for a defamatory statement, so i think it likely that the allegations in the complaint were serious. I see nothing in the ruling indicating specifically, however, what statements are prohibited, other than defamatory statements in a general sense. Certainly a positive outcome, but not, perhaps, a full vindication that a ruling after hearing both sides of the case might have provided. Hopefully this is the end of the dispute. Unfortunately it may not be. I've had a long day, so I hope that this comment hasn't rambled too much or sound like I'm contradicting your opinions. I'm merely suggesting that it may be too early to declare a total victory. 

by RandomPrecision - 2 months ago
Illinois United States
Member Since: Feb 2008
Member Points: 221
by yert - 2 months ago
rhode island usa United States
Member Since: Sep 2007
Member Points: 53

Sounds like a peach... Warm and fuzzy on the outside.  Cold and hard on the inside.

aa-

by RookHouse - 2 months ago
Ohio United States
Member Since: May 2008
Member Points: 157

No, that would be Ed Trice:

  • Inventor of the Capablanca chess ripoff (Gothic Chess)
  • Perpetrator of the attempted scam to sell unsuspecting chess enthusiasts the non-existant book "My 61 Memorable Games"
  • Loser in a $21.2 Million lawsuit for slander and libel
  • Seller of Land on Mars

He's a real "peach".

by spurg - 2 months ago
Los Angeles United States
Member Since: Jul 2008
Member Points: 23

obie trice?

by shuttlechess92 - 2 months ago
California United States
Member Since: Jul 2008
Member Points: 1104

is this trice teh rapper?

 

Add your comment:

Join Chess.com for free to add your comment! Already a member? Then login now to comment.